• 0 Posts
  • 43 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle





  • I can understand why. The motivations and message are a bit deeper than WoK. But UC wouldn’t have happened (in the same way) without WoK first, since I don’t think Kirk had the same hatred towards Klingons before. Distrust sure, but not revenge level hate.

    UC also has that connection with one of the best TNG episodes, Yesterday’s Enterprise.



  • I do prefer the beard, but later Riker without a beard works well. I think it’s because the character and actor have grown into the part at that point and don’t present themselves the same as the early season Riker. I was going to call him “gangly” but I don’t think that’s right, but first season Riker was less sure of things.

    Let’s not forget the other badass old Riker with the peppered gray beard who said “I’ll get the Klingon’s attention”.



  • Correct. Stephanie is the one everyone always refers to for that look she gives Riker in that scene. RIP.

    And for what it’s worth, although the inference seems to always be sexual, I don’t think it needs to be. It can be just as much admiration and “holy shit, captain”. Which is totally justified.

    I also like the look Riker gives when Geordi tells him he already ejected the core before being ordered.





  • If you really want to get the full idea of what Kirk as a captain is like, dive into the old paperback novels. He has a presence of command that many good writers have expanded on, and there’s a reason he’s a legend among the many Starfleet commanders. Although I have a head canon that anyone getting to the point of captaining a starship has similar awesomeness in their character that can face just about anything head on. A 23rd/24th century version of the steely-eyed missile man.

    Which puts a new light on the various captains in all the series that “failed” in some way. Decker and the rest. They were Kirk level, and what they went through still broke them.


  • Given that was the very first filmed episode (as a second pilot) it can be forgiven (The Man Trap was the first aired). I can’t find a reason for picking “T” later on in the series, but it sounds better than “R” when announcing his full name to an alien ship. “Tiberius” didn’t even come along until a later animated episode, and still wasn’t canon except to fans until it was used in The Undiscovered Country.



  • I think at least in TOS (where red shirts originated, perhaps statistically unfairly) all of the red shirts would get a name tagged to them before things went wrong. That seemed to be more of a “red” flag to me, get the regulars in a landing party, oh, and Mr. Johnson too. Yeah, he’s toast.

    Certainly by now someone has done a breakdown comparison of the many series - which series was more deadly to the “new” guy in the group? I don’t think TOS was the worst, and no, whole ships don’t count like Wolf 359.